There is also something intensely masculine about cooking large cuts of meat, or the entirety of an animal, like a turkey. I do it because no one else in my family will. It falls in the same category of dad tasks as removing corpses, fixing toilets, or burials. This I think as I grapple the wet bird from the brine and lift it over the sink, a perverse newborn of sorts, pale and dripping.
We only cook turkeys on Thanksgiving or the odd Christmas, and I write the years in my cookbook dating back to 2006. I do the James Beard method of flipping the bird to ensure even roasting. High heat, high danger. You waddle a bunch of paper towels and just use your hands, as James did (or instructed his assistants to). Be sure not to let the hot juices leak out.
Because the gravy called for white wine and was make ahead (or so complicated it required distinct phases of preparation), my drinking was make ahead too. And I often had a cigar out on my mother-in-law’s deck. If Thanksgiving is all about tradition, mine came down to this.
There is the time we roasted a turkey at mom’s house in Germany and I learned how to do giblet pan gravy from mom’s friend Heidi’s dying ex-husband Alan, who was British and smoked, smoked even in people’s kitchens, smoked over the stove to boot, ashed in the pan without skipping a beat, only winced and kept stirring.
There is the time we roasted a turkey there and could not find a V-rack to elevate the bird off the roasting pan and had to rummage in mom’s medieval barn for a stand-in, and used some old metal spring.
And there are so many turkeys we cooked and ate I can’t remember. Last year’s, which we brined in buttermilk for the promise of a deep-golden skin, but came out only meh and required the dumping of quarts of gross, chicken brine buttermilk solution down the drain.
It is also the dad who carves the meat. The year I was quite buzzed and used the electric carver on the brand new carving board and then joked about it looking like Seal’s scarred face.
How for so many years of my kids’ life I acted like a kid myself, or insisted on remaining one, and am just now starting to see that.
It is perhaps the one holiday we have in the States that requires reflection. We put our hands together in an aspect of prayer, we hold hands at the table, we think about others who don’t have it as good. And then I always put the carcass in a bag and cook it down the next day.
This year will be our last at my mother-in-law Beth’s, who’s putting her house on the market in January and moving to an apartment. It will end a cycle of 15 years or more coming here on a Wednesday and leaving on Friday. I’ve ceased the cigar on the deck afternoon ritual, though I confess I miss looking out over the lake bundled in flannel and puffing. Instead this year we’ll do the turkey trot down in Issaquah and perhaps I’ll go out on the deck with an apple cider or tea.
It’s still dark now, an hour before sunrise, and there’s a creamy line of light on the far side of the lake. Once I’m done here I’ll head home to start the gravy. And as I always do, I’ll put the turkey in a box in the trunk and trot it back over to Beth’s for a final roasting. I am glad I’m not a kid anymore I guess, glad for the time being my kids still are.

What a rich mosaic of memory here, Bill. Especially love that “creamy line of light.” Wishing you and yours a beautiful day!
LikeLiked by 1 person
And to you Stacey! Thank you for reading and happy we could connect as much as we did this year! Enjoy your time and be well!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am grateful for this, Bill! : )
LikeLiked by 1 person
So sweet! Thanks Stacey for making me smile 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
This is one of my least favorite holidays. I’ve made the turkey exactly once, except that for some reason it’s my responsibility to carve the thing. The one time I made it, I did it on the grill. After that one experience … well, lets just say I wish we would do something different with this long weekend. We have hosted Turkey Day at our house as far back as I can recall. I think I was able to convince the wife one time that we should go somewhere Thanksgiving week instead of stay home and cook the same food the same way we did last year.
Part of the problem for me is that most of the traditional foods served on this day are foods I just don’t care for. The other part of the problem is that, for the most part, the people who join us are people I’d just rather not spend time with.
The entire experience is an exercise in patience for me. Patience is not a virtue I have in strong supply.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I should have added … it sounds like you do Turkey Day right and love that you have such wonderful and sensory memories of the thing.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Well thanks buddy! I think so, it’s good to try to take at least one day a year to focus on gratitude.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Every once in awhile, as we sit down to eat, I invite people to say what they’re thankful for. The eye rolls that follow … well, I don’t suggest it anymore. 😉
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yeah I feel you there. We tried to implement that after our one daughter went off to wilderness therapy and they really stressed the value of that practice, but it often feels unnatural for some reason or overly formal. That’s too bad because I think it’s a really important thing.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think it is something that should be embedded more often in our daily existence, and not just forced once a year, but too many people have no interest in really thinking deeply about it.
A little daily grace and thanks and thoughtful reflection wouldn’t be such a bad thing.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Amen to that!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Enjoy your day and the time with your family! You have a lot to be thankful for.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks my friend, you do the same. Appreciate the kind note.
LikeLike
Oh no Mark! That’s too bad! Bad combination for sure. Maybe find a clever way to migrate the traditions over to ham or grilling something else ha ha. I guess you can’t do much about the company though…
LikeLiked by 1 person
I once suggested to my wife that we should have an Italian-themed Thanksgiving. Her response … “Well, you’ll just have to make everything!!” So … that was a no go.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I love it! You could pull that off. Casseroles, cold cuts, and so on. Good idea. Could probably work in some ground turkey too to make it official.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I wasn’t even thinking of it in that way. Just … can we have some of these things flavored differently?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Although, now that I think about it, I wouldn’t mind it. Except … that’s just not the Thanksgiving her family wants.
LikeLike
I’m a bit concerned I didn’t see removing corpses in the dad job description. Fortunately, it hasn’t come up in any performance reviews so far.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ha ha! “Meats expectations,” so to speak…
LikeLike
Happy gathering and warmest reflections, Bill. I’m reading today how we need to practice gratitude, not only together, but for our own thriving. I realise, too, how rarely being positively grateful features in my personal landscape. So yes. More practice. All best wishes to you and yours.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes to gratitude in our personal landscapes as you so beautifully say Tish! Lovely to hear from you and well wishes to you and G! Thanks for reading.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I wonder what ritual I would have for Thanksgiving, should I have been born in the USA. I’ve never cooked a whole turkey like that, Bill. But I might just go turn my attention to gratitude for my coffee and oat porridge breakfast. That’ll do for a start.
I hope you had a wonderful day.
Cheers
DD
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you David! Oat porridge sounds delish. Hope you’re well and thank you for this!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Enjoyed reading this fowl piece, Bill. It’s an odd experience for a not-American; strange and unfamiliar customs, words tha don’t translate.
Our neighbours do a Thanksgiving dinner of some kind; one is from the US. I wanted to ask whether the indigenous peoples celebrate on that day, but didn’t want to appear rude. It’s the “giving thanks to whom?” that’s an insurmountable barrier for me. The insidious rituals of religion. Appreciation Day. I could get behind that.
PS. Loved the child/grownup theme. More there perhaps? 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Bruce! Yes more on the child theme for sure, glad you liked that. I can’t overthink the Thanksgiving thing re: our past history of genocide. I would find no joy in this world if I “went there.” I take what I can! And get lots of joy kibitzing with you old mate. Thanks for reading you fowl sort, you….
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah. Get that. We (Australia) just said no on a referendum to simply listen to the First Nations people. I felt sick.
And a big cackling Yes to sharing (generally) and creating (in particular). I actually wrote for Lonely Keyboards last night. Felt good!
LikeLiked by 1 person
A big cackling Yes to sharing. Leave It! Good job busting out the LK yo’!
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s a lot of turkey (and tradition.) We’ve hosted the last five years, and are only starting to get comfortable with it. I’m even good with flipping the bird (the one in the oven) with a couple big carving forks. Not to worry about the juice though; straight into the drip pan for gravy fixings! Yum. Hope your Thanksgiving went well, with fresh new memories for your kids to trot out in the years to come.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hey thanks fellow bird flipper, that’s really nice! Good on you for hosting and getting comfortable with it, super cool. Brining really helps give it good flavor doesn’t it? I basted more this year than before and it really made a difference on the golden, browning of the skin. Just finished leftovers this week and made our stock! Good times. Hope yours was memorable too, my friend. Be well!
LikeLiked by 1 person
“How for so many years of my kids’ life I acted like a kid myself, or insisted on remaining one, and am just now starting to see that.”
Interesting insight. I’ve become full-on dad these days. I know because when my son sent me a picture of his Christmas tree, I asked, “Did you give it a fresh cut before putting it in the stand?” (For the record, he had.)
LikeLiked by 1 person
Fresh cuts is where it’s at. Glad you liked that insight, it was “real time.” Dad! Love that man. Just started your book this week! My, how you’ve grown 👨
LikeLiked by 1 person